April 9
German de Argumosa and the Belmez Faces
On this date in 1974 German de Argumosa, Spanish Carlist and parapsychologist watched as a face materialized on the hearth of a kitchen fireplace before his astonished gaze. The fireplace was in the home of the Pereira family in Belmez, Spain. This had been going on since August of 1971, with faces spontaneously appearing on the concrete kitchen floor.
The first face that appeared was destroyed and fresh concrete put down, but another appeared shortly after. This time the mayor of Belmez didn't allow the face's destruction, having the concrete removed for study instead. The faces continued to appear in the concrete for the next thirty years; the house at Calle Real 5, Belmez de la Moraleda eventually being advertised to the tourist trade as the House of the Faces.
The faces themselves were both male and female and of differing sizes and expressions. Their appearance was not very lifelike but similar to a drawing or painting of a face. Researchers have claimed it to be a most astonishing case of paranormal phenomena, or an outright hoax, depending on their individual preferences.
Argumosa collaborated with parapsychologist Hans Bender throughout the seventies studying the faces, though curiously neither man ever issued an official report on them. Bender did make passing reference to them in various lectures, primarily concerning the use of plastic sheets to seal areas of the floor where faces were developing. No mention was made, that I can find, referring to any 24 hour safeguards against tampering with the plastic sheeting.
The Institute of Ceramics and Glass analyzed samples taken from two of the faces with the following result: sample one consisted of .96% zinc, .02% barium, .01% copper, .09% phosphorus, and .21% lead. Sample two presented at .40% zinc, .15% barium, .16% copper, .02% copper, .30% phosphorus, and .06% lead. All of which is interesting enough, but doesn't prove much, especially since no information was given concerning how the samples were taken or of which faces, or what tests, exactly, were done. It is interesting to note that that zinc, lead and chromium are common elements in paint.
Proponents of the hoax theory note that there are several ways the faces could have been faked. There could have been various acids used. Since all cements are of an alkaline nature, acid could provide various changes in the chemical structure of the cement. Also, there are agents such as silver nitrate that darken when exposed to sunlight. And then, of course, there are various paints, enamels or stains that could have been used to create the faces.
But then what are we to make of Argumosa's claim that he watched as a face developed on the kitchen hearth? Supporting the believer's side are the parapsychologists like Argumosa, who was unlikely to have lied (or been fooled), as well as the controls (plastic sheeting) that were in place. But were they tamper-proof controls? There was a motive in the village economy, which was certainly helped a great deal by the faces of Belmez.
Maria Gomez died in February 2004, age 85. After her death popular psychic Pedro Amoros looked for, and found, a new wave of 'Belmez faces'. However, in November of that year the newspaper El Mundo published an article claiming that the municipal government was in league with the new crop of parapsychologists in faking the faces, trying to restore the village's profitable attraction.
In May, 2007, Javier Cavanilles and Francico Manez published a book titled The Faces of Belmez in which they give their theory of the scam, and point to Maria's son Diego Pereira as the perpetrator. And there the matter rests.
Were the original faces a hoax, as the second crop surely were? Or a legitimate phenomena? Nobody knows for certain.